Skip to Content

We Don't Have an Evidence Problem in Education. We Have a Trust Problem.

By Joaquin Tamayo, VP, Public Impact and Engagement, CIS National | Nov. 16, 2026

Joaquin Tamayo"I had goals, but I didn't always know the exact steps to take to reach them." That's how Eric Carr, an alum of Communities In Schools® (CIS®) of Charlotte-Mecklenburg, describes what it felt like before someone in his school made space for his questions, guided him, and helped him build the skills he needed. Today he's in college, building a career, still growing as a leader.

Communities In Schools is the nation’s leading provider of integrated student supports. Through relationships with caring adults who work in schools and across communities, we connect students to school and community resources, so they show up to school prepared and ready to learn.  

I could tell you 200 stories like Eric's. That's actually the problem.

For almost 30 years in this field, I've watched stories like his get told, get applauded, and then vanish the moment the conversation turns to policy.

Here's the paradox we live inside. Communities In Schools has 50 years of some of the most rigorous quantitative outcomes in education — attendance, graduation, lifetime earnings, tax revenue, causal research out of Opportunity Insights and Harvard's EdRedesign Lab. Fifty years of proof that we know how to support even the most vulnerable students to succeed. And yet, according to Gallup, only 32 percent of Americans say they're satisfied with public education today.

That was never an evidence problem. It’s a trust problem, and you cannot regression-table your way out of a trust problem. For 50 years, stories like Eric's sat outside the evidence base — real, true, and unusable to anyone writing policy. That's the gap our Community Wisdom Project (CWP) was built to close. As of September 2026, over 200 individuals have contributed their authentic personal accounts, called “stories,” to the CWP. Communities In Schools is taking our communities' voices directly to policymakers and sector leaders across the country, supplying them with the wisdom they need to make smart decisions.

With the CWP, we built a relationship-based methodology that turns real accounts into something a legislator can actually act on: a pipeline running from stories to patterns to analysis to policy recommendations to change. It's guided by leading policy experts and researchers, but it starts — and stays grounded — with the people doing the work and living its consequences: students, families, educators, alumni.

One pattern especially worth highlighting surfaced across dozens of these stories, and it isn't just a feeling — it's a design principle. Help works when it's offered before anyone has to ask for it, offered like a gift, not a means test. A family in Washington state, describing the day they lost everything to a fire, put it plainly: "Imagine losing everything... someone comes and tells you: I'm going to give you a card so you can buy food, I have some jackets, I'll get you shoes... any help, any support, any word of encouragement matters, because you can't find it in yourself."

That's not sentiment. That's a policy test, and too many of our systems fail it. We build processes that make a struggling family prove they're desperate enough before we'll help. Every one of those gates works against the thing that actually works: a trusted adult, already in the building, already knowing your name, before the crisis ever gets that far.

We hold that human truth to the same rigor as our data. Take class-size reduction — the single most heavily studied intervention in American education. Dollar for dollar, Communities In Schools returns roughly 10 times more in lifetime earnings than class-size reduction does, on the metric this field trusts most.

Research shows that three years of CIS support generates $9,750 in additional lifetime federal tax revenue. That's not a pilot program's hope. That's 50 years of practice, measured honestly against the field's own gold standard. 

We didn't call it the Community Data Project, because wisdom isn't something a machine generates or a bureaucracy approves. It's flesh-and-blood people doing the work and living its consequences, in equal measure.

This year, America turns 250 years old. At the very beginning, we wrote down a promise: liberty and justice for all. We have 50 years of proof and 200 stories and counting. We know how to keep that promise.

It's time to stop admiring the evidence and let’s get to work.

Joaquin Tamayo is the VP of Public Impact and Engagement at Communities In Schools National Office. 

↑ TOP